Pittsburgh and Votto followup

Reds lineup vs. Pirates

Phillips 4
Lewis 7
Votto 3
Bruce 9
Frazier 5
Stubbs 8
Hanigan 2
Janish 6
Bailey 1

*Getting back to the hot button issue of the week and some hopefully final thoughts…let’s end the comparisons of Joey Votto not moving to LF for Yonder Alonso to Albert Pujols playing 3B earlier this season for the Cardinals or Joe Mauer’s start in RF last night for the Twins

Apples and oranges.

Pujols’ move was temporary because the Cardinals were in a pinch without David Freese. He also came up as a third baseman so it wasn’t entirely foreign. Yet in those seven games and four starts, he committed three errors in 17 chances. Not exactly robust, eh?

As for Mauer, the Twins were in a real big shorthanded situation last night. Three of their outfielders were injured. Another guy had a family leave. Someone they called up from the Minors had a flight issue and missed the game. Mauer is a former three-sport star in high school and a great athlete.

I would imagine had the Reds been in real peril, Votto would move anywhere they asked him for a night. Just like a pitcher would play the outfield in a 19 inning game or Paul Janish would pitch mop up in a blowout. Let’s just move on.

*Also in my Votto story last night, I made a mistake and should own up to it. I said that he made clear he would explore free agency when signing his three-year contract in January. He did not say or articulate that. What I should have said is the three-year deal, which ends in 2013 when he’d be eligible for the first, was a clear signal he’d explore free agency. Big difference. I apologize for the foul up.

*Speaking of Janish and being shorthanded, I was reading the game story comments (I actually do that sometimes) and saw I was hammered for using that term, shorthanded, as the Reds did not pinch-hit for Janish in the sixth inning with two outs and two on while down 1-0. I repeat, they were down by a 1-0 score.

Miguel Cairo has one inning at shortstop last season and a total of 14 innings logged over 4 games since 2009. Todd Frazier hasn’t played shortstop since 2008 at Class A Sarasota. In a 1-0 game, you want the most important infield spot covered by someone not comfortable there for 3-4 innings? This isn’t Little League. It’s just not simple to put a dude there and expect instant defense. Obviously, in the ninth inning when things were a little more desperate, lifting Janish was the right thing to do.

*And incidentally, Dusty Baker planned to use Cairo at SS and either Ramon Hernandez or Frazier at 3B.

*Moving back to the present and future, don’t forget that Saturday’s game was switched to a 4:11 p.m. ET start because it’s on FOX.

5 Comments

’nuff said……let’s play ball!!

Can we at least admit then that Walt and Dusty have no plan then with Alonso?
Curt

On one of last week’s telecasts they were showing footage of Scott Rolen working with Alonso at 3b. I think that’s probably the path to take at this juncture. I think maybe Rolen is past the day that he is going to be major factor in the lineup although his defense is still pretty darn good. If Scott is willing to work with Alonso on his defense at third I think that’s great and a very positive move.

You made another mistake……Alonso has a 4th option year…..So Alonso MAY be sent down to play in Louisville in 2012…..However, in 2013, Alonso must be on the 250man roster.

AMEN!!! you can corble together an infield (or lineup) for a couple innings or a game in an emergency situation…..but i wouldn’t want that same lineup every day……

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 455 other followers

%d bloggers like this: